Ordinary
07/08/2026
SOOOO... YOU WALK INTO A TAVERN.
Hidden in plain sight, down an ordinary street in New Haven, lies a place whispered about by adventurers, witches, wandering bards, cryptid hunters, and those wise enough to seek a proper drink after a long journey.
For the next four months, Ordinary leaves this world behind.
Step inside a tavern where monsters are welcome, legends come to life, and every candlelit corner has a story to tell. Expect enchanted cocktails, curious creatures, forgotten relics, fine wine, craft beer, and enough magic to make you question what’s real.
Your adventure begins tonight.
* Roll for Initiative – Cast a d20 and let fate decide your cocktail. Fortune favors the bold... but beware the Evil Wizard.
* Bard’s Time – Daily from 5–7 PM, enjoy tavern favorites at a special price while the bard’s charm works its magic.
* Tuesdays: Bard’s Night – Vinylry provides the soundtrack while Bard’s Time specials last all evening.
* Wednesdays: Guild Night – Gather a party of four or more for Adventurer’s Feasts and large-format libations worthy of the guild hall.
* Thursdays: Wizards of Whiskey – Journey through whiskey flights curated for apprentices and archmages alike.
* The Blood Moon Ball – On the last Wednesday of each month, enter a world of myths, monsters, fantasy, and folklore with trivia hosted by Eric Bruce of Weirdo Wonderland.
Along the way you may encounter:
• Goblins.
• Witches.
• Vampires.
• Forgotten kings.
• Cryptids.
• The occasional portal.
One bathroom may lead to the Labyrinth.
The other... well... you’ll find out.
We are not a speakeasy.
Though if the King’s Men come looking, we’d appreciate it if you forgot you were ever here.
We keep secrets.
Welcome to the tavern.
Your seat by the fire is waiting.
06/11/2026
Coming Soon! Check out the new cocktail event theme coming in July. We’ve done Twin Peaks, Clue, Wes Anderson and you found out What We Drink in the Shadows last summer. More to come as button up the rest of the drinks, décor, art show, monthly trivia and more. Another fun summer in New Haven!
☠ Weirdo Wonderland ☠ Joe Capobianco
04/02/2026
So, you walk into a tavern… parched and peckish. is now offering the Tavern Feast 🍺🌭🥨! One liter of lager, a bratwurst and the giant Bavarian pretzel for only 28 gold pieces. Available all day and dark nights.
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Category
Contact the club
Telephone
Website
Address
990 Chapel Street
New Haven, CT
06510
Opening Hours
| Tuesday | 5pm - 12am |
| Wednesday | 5pm - 12am |
| Thursday | 5pm - 12am |
| Friday | 5pm - 12am |
| Saturday | 5pm - 12am |