TrimnerBeckham, PLLC

Nonprofit Tax Risk & Strategy Series (Part 1): Are You at Risk? The Hidden Tax Risks Nonprofits Overlook

Many nonprofit organizations believe they are compliant because they file their annual Form 990 on time.
But compliance goes far beyond filing.
In practice, most IRS issues arise not from missed deadlines—but from misunderstood rules, incomplete processes, and undocumented decisions.
The reality is that many organizations are exposed to risk without realizing it.

📊 Compliance vs. Risk
Filing your Form 990 is only one part of compliance.
The IRS evaluates whether an organization is:
• Operating in furtherance of its exempt purpose
• Avoiding private benefit
• Maintaining proper governance and oversight
• Reporting activities accurately and consistently
An organization can file on time—and still face significant compliance risks.

🔹 Common Hidden Risks
Unrelated Business Activities
Many organizations generate revenue through activities that may not be substantially related to their mission.
Examples include:
• Advertising income
• Sponsorship arrangements
• Fee-for-service programs
Not all revenue is treated the same for tax purposes.

Compensation and Private Benefit
Payments to officers, directors, or related parties must be reasonable and properly documented.
Even well-intentioned arrangements can raise concerns if:
• Compensation is not benchmarked
• Decisions are not independently approved
• Documentation is limited

Related Party Transactions
Transactions involving insiders are not prohibited—but they are closely scrutinized.
These transactions must be:
• At fair market value
• Properly approved
• Fully disclosed on Form 990

Governance and Oversight
The IRS uses Form 990 to evaluate governance practices, including:
• Board independence
• Conflict of interest policies
• Documentation of decisions
Weak governance structures can signal broader compliance issues.

Filing and Reporting Gaps
Beyond Form 990, nonprofits have additional filing obligations, including:
• Form 990-T for unrelated business income
• Payroll tax filings
• Information returns such as Forms 1099
Missing or incomplete filings may indicate systemic issues.

📌 The Most Common Issue: Lack of Structure
Many organizations do not have a formal compliance framework.
As a result:
• Responsibilities are unclear
• Processes are inconsistent
• Documentation is incomplete
This often leads to reactive compliance—addressing issues only when they arise.

📊 A Practical Perspective
Strong organizations treat compliance as an ongoing process—not a once-a-year requirement.
This includes:
• Regular review of activities and revenue streams
• Clear governance and approval processes
• Proper documentation of key decisions
• Coordination between leadership, finance, and advisors

📌 Why This Matters
Compliance risks can lead to:
• IRS inquiries or audits
• Financial penalties
• Reputational concerns
• Potential loss of tax-exempt status
Many of these risks are preventable with proper structure and oversight.

📌 Final Thought
Most nonprofit risks are not obvious.
They arise from everyday decisions—how revenue is earned, how compensation is set, and how transactions are structured.
Understanding these risks is the first step toward protecting your organization and its mission.

🔜 In Part 2, we’ll take a closer look at one of the most misunderstood areas of nonprofit taxation:
Unrelated Business Income (UBI) vs. mission-related revenue

IRS Audit Triggers for Nonprofits (Part 6): Filing & Compliance Failures That Create Risk

Timely and accurate filing is a fundamental requirement for maintaining tax-exempt status.
While many organizations focus on operations and mission delivery, filing and compliance failures are among the most common—and avoidable—reasons nonprofits face IRS scrutiny.
Understanding these risks is essential to protecting your organization’s exempt status.

📊 Why Filing Compliance Matters
Tax-exempt organizations are required to file an annual information return, typically Form 990, 990-EZ, or 990-N.
These filings allow the IRS to:
• Monitor compliance with tax-exempt requirements
• Review financial activity and governance practices
• Identify potential areas of concern
Failure to file or filing inaccurate returns can lead to significant consequences.

🔹 Common Audit Triggers
Late or Missed Filings
One of the most common issues is failing to file on time.
⚠️ Nonprofits that fail to file for three consecutive years automatically lose their tax-exempt status.
Even a single late filing may raise concerns, particularly if it becomes a pattern.

Filing the Wrong Form
Nonprofits must file the correct version of Form 990 based on their gross receipts and total assets.
Filing the wrong form can result in:
• Incomplete reporting
• Incorrect disclosures
• Increased risk of IRS follow-up

Incomplete or Inaccurate Returns
Errors or omissions on Form 990 can raise red flags, including:
• Missing schedules
• Inconsistent financial information
• Incorrect responses to governance questions
⚠️ The IRS reviews returns for both completeness and consistency.

Failure to Report Unrelated Business Income (UBI)
Organizations with unrelated business activities must report income on Form 990-T.
Failure to report UBI may result in:
• Underreported taxable income
• Additional tax and penalties
• Increased audit risk

Failure to Issue Required Filings and Forms
Nonprofits have additional filing responsibilities beyond Form 990, including:
• Form 1099 reporting for contractors
• Payroll tax filings (Forms 941, W-2, etc.)
• State filings and registrations
⚠️ Missing these filings can signal broader compliance issues.

Lack of Internal Filing Controls
Many compliance failures occur because organizations lack structured processes.
Common issues include:
• No calendar or tracking system for deadlines
• Unclear responsibility for filings
• Limited oversight or review

📌 The Most Common Issue: Reactive vs. Proactive Compliance
Many nonprofits approach compliance reactively—filing returns only when deadlines approach.
This often leads to:
• Last-minute preparation
• Missing information
• Increased risk of errors
A proactive approach to compliance helps ensure accuracy and consistency.

📊 A Practical Approach
Organizations can reduce filing and compliance risk by:
• Maintaining a compliance calendar with key deadlines
• Assigning clear responsibility for filings
• Reviewing filings before submission
• Tracking all required federal and state filings
• Coordinating between finance, leadership, and advisors
Consistency and planning are key to effective compliance.

📌 Why This Matters
Filing and compliance failures can result in:
• Automatic revocation of tax-exempt status
• Penalties and interest
• Increased IRS scrutiny
• Reputational risk with donors and stakeholders
Because Form 990 is publicly available, errors or late filings may also impact public perception.

📌 Final Thought
Filing compliance is not just an administrative requirement—it is essential to maintaining an organization’s tax-exempt status.
By implementing structured processes and maintaining accurate records, organizations can reduce risk and focus on their mission with confidence.

🔚 Series Wrap-Up
Throughout this series, we’ve covered key areas the IRS reviews during nonprofit audits:
• Unrelated business income (UBI)
• Compensation and private benefit
• Related party transactions
• Governance and internal controls
• Filing and compliance practices
Each of these areas plays a role in demonstrating that an organization is operating in compliance with its exempt purpose.