True Whey Creamery

NEW RELEASE🎉🥳
We now have our hard ice cream available to enjoy while looking at the cows in the pasture, rocking in the rocking chairs or right inside the cafe. We have True Whey Creamery Sugarhouse Joy and Serenity Swirl made by Gilligan’s as well as Gilligan’s Chocolate Cookie Monster ready to enjoy in a cone or a dish.
We also have Affogato’s available! The combination of Gilligan’s creamy vanilla ice cream and Milk House coffee Roasters Espresso is dreamy, you just might need two😋

🧀 **It’s National Cheese Day… and we’re feeling grate about it!** 🧀

If you’re looking to make today a little cheddar, stop by the Farm Store and treat yourself to some truly gouda cheese!

We’re proud to carry artisan farmstead cheeses from **Eden Valley Creamery** and **Muranda Cheese Company**—two creameries with distinct styles, incredible craftsmanship, and plenty of flavor. Jenny has worked closely with both companies over the years and can help you find the perfect cheese for your next charcuterie board, dinner, or to snack on.

Whether you like it sharp, creamy, aged, or bold, there’s a cheese here with your name on it.

🧀 Come stock up before these favorites are gone—there’s no whey you’ll regret it!

See you soon! 🧀❤️

On Mother’s Day, we honor not only the women who have raised children, but also every woman who nurtures, comforts, guides, and loves with a mother’s heart. Whether through family, friendship, mentorship, caregiving, or quiet acts of kindness, these women make the world softer, stronger, and more compassionate. Today we celebrate all who give of themselves so generously and care for others in ways that truly reflect the spirit of motherhood.
Today we celebrate all mothers so those who stop in the cafe can get a drip coffee for $1.50/ or $1.00 off a specialty drink❤️

Place your orders for our Mother’s Day Specials to celebrate all the special moms in your life! Orders can be placed by messaging us or calling the cafe. You can pick the items up during open hours through Saturday.

The sun is out and we are feeling extra springy today as we now have Westfall Maple Candy and Hillcrest/Ripley Farms Orange Cream only available for a limited time!

The NEW menu is now available! Stop in to try our new sandwiches!
We will also be offering iced lattes, coffee and cold brew!
The original menu will still be available for a limited time as we transition! As always you can message us your order and we can get it ready for you to pick up.
We are open
Tuesday 6:30am-1:00pm
Wednesday 6:30am-1:00pm
Thursday 6:30am-1:00pm
Friday 6:30am-3:00pm
Saturday 6:30am-3:00pm

A huge thank you to Lesley, Bob, Christy and Debbie for running and watching over the store and cafe while we were away! We were able to attend the World Guernsey Conference in Australia and meet Guernsey breeders from around the world while touring farms and on farm processing plants! I will post pictures and more details from our trip in a little while!
Stop in today as we have fresh milk, cheese, muffins and speciality drinks! We are here until 1:00pm today and then our hours go back to normal next week!
We have exciting news and a new menu coming next week☺️

While the boss-lady is away, we’re trying new things! Come on out to True Whey Creamery to try the new Lemon Blueberry Muffins! This dreary weather deserves a coffee and treat. ☕️

We’re here 7am-1pm Friday and Saturday.

The New Ice Cream Recipes have arrived!!!! Gilligan’s Ice Cream made our ice cream for us!
Serenity Swirl is vanilla ice cream with a white chocolate
Lavender swirl
Sugar house Joy is ice cream with maple syrup and blueberries
We are so excited for this collaboration with Gilligan’s stop in and pick up yours today!