Dr. OMEB

Classic rock purists often claim this heavy metal cover ruined a sacred 1973 masterpiece, but Bob Seger himself actually defended it. Seger publicly praised Lars Ulrich's heavy, driving drum arrangement, admitting that Lars gave the track the powerful, aggressive heartbeat his quiet original studio version always lacked.

​Does Metallica’s heavy, distorted aggression capture the miserable grind of touring better than Seger’s quiet, acoustic original?

​

Everyone assumes the lead guitarist handled all the leads on this 1986 thrash masterpiece, but James Hetfield actually stepped up to play this iconic, melodic first solo himself. Hetfield insisted the middle section needed to feel soulful and carefully structured rather than just another chaotic shredfest, proving the rhythm player had serious lead chops.

Does Hetfield's melodic phrasing actually make for a better, more memorable solo than Hammett’s shred solo?

Dave Mustaine was driving home from a kickboxing session with a severe headache when inspiration struck so hard he scribbled the opening lyrics right onto a sushi restaurant receipt. The demo arrangement was actually a clunky mess until producer Max Norman stepped in and forced the band to ruthlessly restructure the entire song into the driving groove we know today.

Does the magic of this track come from Mustaine's raw inspiration or the producer's polished arrangement?

Vincent Furnier, the man behind Alice Cooper, described himself as basically Ferris Bueller in high school: popular, ran cross-country, and came from a family of evangelical ministers. The national anthem of school rebellion was pure theater, not biography.

Does knowing Cooper never lived this rebellion make it better or worse — great art, or a really convincing pose?