My Tomato Pie
12/24/2025
Holiday Hours
Christmas Eve: 11am-4pm
Christmas: Closed
10/30/2025
Join us this weekend. One of our weekends specials. Spicy BBQ Pulled Pork Pinsa Flatbread - Tender pulled pork tossed in our spicy peach BBQ sauce, topped with melted smoked gouda and fresh jalapeño peppers on our signature crispy-fluffy pinsa crust. A perfect balance of sweet heat and smoky flavor in every bite.
Amherst - Spicy BBQ Pulled Pork Pinsa Flatbread Order Spicy BBQ Pulled Pork Pinsa Flatbread online from Amherst. Tender pulled pork tossed in our spicy peach BBQ sauce, topped with melted smoked gouda and fresh jalapeño peppers on our signature crispy-fluffy pinsa crust. A perfect balance of sweet heat and smoky flavor in every bite.
07/05/2025
🔥 Tonight’s Special: Smothered Lemon Pepper Chicken 🔥
Get ready for a flavor-packed favorite! Our Smothered Lemon Pepper Chicken starts with a juicy grilled chicken breast, topped with a creamy blend of artichokes, roasted red peppers, breadcrumbs, and mozzarella. Served over lemon tarragon rice with tender asparagus, and finished with a rich roasted garlic herb butter.
🍋 Creamy. Savory. Irresistible.
Only for a limited time—don’t miss it!
https://mytomatopie.com/order/mytomatopie/item-smothered-lemon-pepper-chicken_32fc0f9c-241d-4ba7-bb58-d18efa559e2d
05/03/2025
Indulge in our mouthwatering Boneless Beef Short Rib—slow-braised until fork-tender and served over creamy mashed potatoes with sweet glazed carrots, all topped with a rich demi-glace. The perfect blend of savory and comforting flavors, made fresh just for you!
Tag someone you'd love to dine with tonight! 👇
https://mytomatopie.com/order/mytomatopie/item-boneless-beef-short-rib_79615a81-3fe1-4bed-a664-7336307e3173
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Category
Contact the restaurant
Telephone
Website
Address
3055 Niagara Falls Boulevard
Amherst, NY
14228
Opening Hours
| Monday | 11am - 10pm |
| Tuesday | 11am - 9pm |
| Wednesday | 11am - 9pm |
| Thursday | 11am - 10:30pm |
| Friday | 11am - 10pm |
| Saturday | 11am - 10pm |
| Sunday | 12pm - 8pm |